RedlineREDLINE

← The Redline Blog

Mortgage Closing Disclosure Red Flags: The TRID Tolerance Buckets and the 60-Day Cure

TRID gives you 3 business days to compare the Closing Disclosure to the Loan Estimate. Zero-tolerance fees that increased are recoverable as a cure within 60 days. The federal rule, the cure script, the buckets.

5 min read

Mortgage Closing Disclosure Red Flags: The TRID Tolerance Buckets and the 60-Day Cure

Three tolerance buckets.

The Closing Disclosure arrived three days before your scheduled closing. The total cash to close is $4,800 higher than the Loan Estimate you signed off on six weeks ago. The closer at the title company says it's normal and offers to email a comparison spreadsheet. Your real estate agent says "happens all the time." Your loan officer says "rates moved."

None of those answers are the federal answer. TRID gives you three business days to compare the two documents against three tolerance buckets, and most "surprise" closing costs are recoverable as a cure within 60 days of consummation. Most buyers do not know this window exists. Most lenders are counting on that.

TL;DR

  • The Closing Disclosure must match the Loan Estimate within three TRID buckets: zero tolerance, 10 percent cumulative, unlimited.
  • Three business days to compare before consummation, by federal rule.
  • Zero-tolerance fees that increased are recoverable as a cure within 60 days. The lender owes you the difference.
  • The cure citation is 12 CFR §1026.19(f)(2)(v). Include it in your demand letter.
  • Most buyers waive these protections by closing without comparison. Don't.

What TRID actually requires

The TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure rule was issued by the CFPB in 2015 and codified at 12 CFR §1026.19. Two documents and two windows:

The Loan Estimate, delivered within 3 business days of application. Lists the loan terms, monthly payment, estimated closing costs, and cash to close. Locks the lender into the disclosed numbers within the tolerance buckets below.

The Closing Disclosure, delivered at least 3 business days before consummation (the date you sign the closing papers). Must match the Loan Estimate within the tolerance buckets, with any differences explained and justified by a "changed circumstance."

If the lender violates the timing, the consumer can delay closing until the 3-day window is satisfied. If the lender violates the tolerance, the consumer can demand a cure. Both are federal rights.

The three tolerance buckets

CFPB Regulation Z 12 CFR §1026.19(e)(3) defines three categories of closing cost charges, each with a different tolerance.

Bucket 1: Zero tolerance

These cannot increase from Loan Estimate to Closing Disclosure. At all.

  • Lender fees (origination, processing, underwriting, application)
  • Transfer taxes (state and local)
  • Fees for services where the lender did not allow the consumer to shop
  • Fees for services where the consumer used a provider from the lender's preferred list

Any increase in any of these is recoverable as a cure. The lender owes you the difference within 60 days of consummation.

Bucket 2: 10 percent cumulative tolerance

These can increase, but the total category increase cannot exceed 10 percent.

  • Recording fees
  • Fees for third-party services where the consumer was allowed to shop but used the lender's preferred provider

If the category total is $500 on the Loan Estimate and $600 on the Closing Disclosure, the increase is $100 which is 20 percent of $500. Anything above 10 percent ($50 in this case) is recoverable.

Bucket 3: Unlimited tolerance

These can change without restriction.

  • Prepaid interest (depends on closing date)
  • Property insurance premium
  • Escrow amounts
  • Fees for services where the consumer shopped and chose an unaffiliated provider
  • Fees for services not required by the lender (optional services the buyer chose)

These are the legitimate sources of variance. Most "surprise" closing cost increases are not in this bucket.

A typographic poster reading THREE BUCKETS on white paper with a red ink underline

The cure procedure

Once you identify a tolerance violation, the procedure is well-marked.

Step 1: Document the violation in writing

Pull up the Loan Estimate and the Closing Disclosure side by side. For each disputed line:

  • Identify the specific line item on both documents
  • Identify the tolerance bucket (Section 8.A.1, "Section 9: Origination Charges," etc.)
  • Calculate the increase in dollars and percentage
  • Note whether the increase exceeds the bucket tolerance

Step 2: Send the cure demand letter

Demand letter template:

RE: Cure Demand under 12 CFR §1026.19(f)(2)(v)
Loan Number: [number]
Closing Date: [date]

The Closing Disclosure dated [date] shows the following charge(s)
that exceed the tolerance applicable under TRID:

[Line item], Loan Estimate amount: $X, Closing Disclosure amount:
$Y, increase: $Z. This charge is in the zero-tolerance category
per 12 CFR §1026.19(e)(3)(i) [or 10-percent category per (ii)].

Pursuant to 12 CFR §1026.19(f)(2)(v), I request a refund of $Z
within 60 days of consummation.

If this cure is not provided, I intend to file a complaint with
the CFPB at consumerfinance.gov/complaint.

Send via email and certified mail. Copy the loan officer, the underwriter, and the closing department.

Step 3: Escalate if needed

Most lenders honor the cure request within days because the alternative is a CFPB complaint and a regulatory file. If the lender refuses, file at consumerfinance.gov/complaint within 60 days of consummation. The complaint creates a regulatory record and typically pressures the lender to settle within 30 days.

The "changed circumstance" exception

The one situation where bucket violations are legitimate is a documented changed circumstance. The CFPB defines this narrowly:

  • Property value change: appraisal came in different than expected
  • Borrower credit change: credit score dropped after Loan Estimate
  • New information: title issue, survey issue, environmental issue not known at application
  • Consumer request: buyer added new services not previously requested
  • Settlement service provider unavailability: shopped provider could not perform

A simple "we forgot to include this fee" is not a changed circumstance. A "the underwriter required additional processing" is not a changed circumstance. The lender must document the circumstance and reissue a corrected Loan Estimate before the change is allowed.

What changed in 2024-2025

CFPB has continued active TRID enforcement. 2024 enforcement actions against several mid-size lenders cited repeated tolerance violations. The 3-day rule waiver, which lenders sometimes ask buyers to sign, was specifically called out in CFPB guidance as unenforceable in many cases (the waiver is technically available only for "bona fide personal financial emergency").

Before consummation: the 30-minute pre-closing scan

Three documents in 30 minutes:

  1. The original Loan Estimate from application
  2. The most recent Closing Disclosure from 3 days before closing
  3. Any corrected Closing Disclosure the lender issued (rare but happens)

Compare line by line. Anything in the zero-tolerance bucket that changed is the cure target. Anything in the 10-percent bucket that exceeds 10 percent is the cure target. Anything in the unlimited bucket is legitimate variance.

If the closing is tomorrow and the discrepancy is large, ask for a 3-business-day delay to get a corrected Closing Disclosure. The lender can issue one electronically; the delay is short. The home buying red flags pillar covers the broader at-signing checklist.

Redline reads a Loan Estimate and a Closing Disclosure in plain English. Photograph both, paste them, or upload PDFs. Redline compares line by line, identifies the tolerance bucket for each charge, and flags the lines where the increase exceeds the federal cap. Redline drafts the cure demand letter with the right CFR citation in seconds. One scan, one dollar. Available on iOS and Android.

Frequently asked questions

What is TRID and what does it require?
TRID stands for TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure rule. It was issued by the CFPB in 2015 and combines disclosures previously required by the Truth in Lending Act and the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act. TRID requires the lender to issue a Loan Estimate within 3 business days of application and a Closing Disclosure at least 3 business days before consummation. The two documents must match within defined tolerance buckets. Most violations involve last-minute changes to the Closing Disclosure that exceed the buckets, which give the buyer a right to a cure.
What are the TRID tolerance buckets?
CFPB Regulation Z 12 CFR §1026.19(e)(3) defines three buckets. Zero tolerance: lender fees, transfer taxes, fees for services where the lender did not allow the consumer to shop, and fees for services where the consumer used a settlement service provider on the lender's list. These cannot increase at all. 10 percent cumulative tolerance: recording fees and fees for third-party services where the consumer was allowed to shop but used the lender's preferred provider. These can increase but the total category increase cannot exceed 10 percent. Unlimited: prepaid interest, property insurance premium, escrow amounts, fees for services where the consumer shopped and chose an unaffiliated provider, and fees for services not required by the lender.
How long do I have to compare the Closing Disclosure to the Loan Estimate?
Federal law requires the lender to deliver the Closing Disclosure at least 3 business days before consummation. The 3-day rule was specifically designed to give buyers time to compare the two documents and demand cures. If a significant change occurs after the initial Closing Disclosure (such as the APR increasing by more than 1/8 percent or a prepayment penalty being added), the lender must issue a corrected Closing Disclosure and restart the 3-day window. Some lenders pressure buyers to waive this window; the waiver is technically available but rarely advisable.
What can I do if my Closing Disclosure has fees that were not on the Loan Estimate?
File a written cure request with the lender citing 12 CFR §1026.19(f)(2)(v). The lender must refund any zero-tolerance fee that increased and any 10-percent-bucket increase above the allowed amount. The refund must be issued no later than 60 days after consummation. Most lenders honor the cure request within days of receiving it because the alternative is a CFPB complaint and potential enforcement. If the lender refuses, file a CFPB complaint at consumerfinance.gov/complaint within 60 days.
Can the lender add fees at closing?
Only under specific circumstances. New zero-tolerance fees cannot be added unless the buyer requested a new service or unless a "changed circumstance" occurred (defined narrowly: change in property value, change in borrower credit, new information not previously available). A simple oversight by the lender does not qualify as a changed circumstance. New 10-percent-bucket fees can be added but must stay within the cumulative cap. New unlimited-bucket fees can be added without restriction. Most surprise closing fees fall in zero or 10 percent bucket and are recoverable.
Should I delay closing to fix a Closing Disclosure problem?
Sometimes. If the discrepancy is small (under $200) and the closing is time-sensitive (rate lock expiring, seller hardline date), it can make sense to close and file the cure request afterward. If the discrepancy is large ($500+) or includes a category change (a new prepayment penalty, an APR increase), delaying 3 to 7 days to get a corrected disclosure is usually worth the cost. Most rate locks have a 7-day extension available. Most sellers accept a documented lender problem as grounds for a brief delay.

Keep reading